The sequent calculus for the modal logic d article pdf available in bollettino della unione matematica italiana a 73 january 1993 with 81 reads how we measure reads. Every logical rule corresponds to a connective or quantifier. Usually, for every logical connective, a sequent calculus has introduction rules into both antecedent and succedent. The reason is roughly that, using the language of natural deduction, in sequent calculus every rule is an introduction rule which introduces a term on either side of a sequent with no elimination rules. Sequent calculus as a compiler intermediate language. Sequent calculus more about first order logic thus far, we have two contrasting presentations of first order logic. However, the semantics of contingency is different from that of validity, because in many rules the main formula is actually moved to the opposite part of the sequent. A sequent calculus and theorem prover for standard. Main differences and relations between sequent calculus. Calculus i or needing a refresher in some of the early topics in calculus.
We assume the reader to be familiar with the basic notions of sequent calculi cf. A sequent calculus for a logic of contingencies sciencedirect. Theorem introduction and the name of the sequent or theorem being introduced. Sequent calculus is, in essence, a style of formal logical argumentation where every line of a proof is a conditional tautology called a sequent by gerhard gentzen instead of an unconditional tautology. The aim of this master thesis is to develop an algorithm for automated proof searches in the sequent calculus for firstorder logic with equality fo. Proving theorems is not for the mathematicians anymore. The systems are formulated as sequent calculi for classical. In this logic, to each agent i is associated a knowledge modality k i, so that the. Sequent calculus was introduced by gentzen in 1935. For that reason we decide to made the sequent calculus trainer smart. It is probably the first sequent calculus in the literature where the corresponding term calculus is considered to have an explicit substitution operator.
Oct 25, 2019 introduction to sequent calculus tudor jebelean risclinz johannes kepler university october 25, 2019 abstract this is a tutorial introduction to sequent calculus, starting from a certain natural style of proving, and based on an example. Im looking for a good introductory resource on sequent calculus suitable for someone who has studied natural deduction before. Books and online resources are both ok, as long as each rule of inference and any notational convention is explained. Sequent calculus for justi cations yury savateev university of bern abstract we present a cutfree sequent calculus that can internalize its own proofs, providing a new justi cation system for modal logic. This means that working backward every unapplication of such a rule makes the sequent necessarily simpler. We extend the notion of a sequent obtaining what we call a 2 sequent. In proof theory and mathematical logic, sequent calculus is a family of formal systems sharing a certain style of inference and certain formal properties. You will see what the questions are, and you will see an important part of the answer. This introductory chapter will deal primarily with the sequent calculus, and resolution, and to lesser extent, the hilbertstyle proof systems and the natural. We introduce a calculus for handling integer arithmetic in. Prooftheoretic methods in nonclassical logic an introduction.
Each conditional tautology is inferred from other conditional tautologies on earlier lines in a. The introduction of the abstraction on the righthand side of a sequent corresponds to the universal quanti cation. Default logic, stable models, autoepistemic logic, sequent calculus ams subject classi. A propositional clausal sequent is an expression of the form. Nj, nk, and then moved to sequent calculus lj,lk which he found easier to work with for consistency proofs.
What can sequent calculus do for functional programs. If the sequent calculus has subformula properties, i. Its a way of deducing whether or not a statement is true, but unlike proofs where the prover makes wild leaps of deduction from one. And for a book very carefully written for selfstudy, goldreis propositional and predicate calculus seems excellent. Several authors have proposed many sequent calculus for s5, however, each of them presents some di.
The natural deduction give a more mathematicallike approach to reasoning while the sequent calculus give more structural and symmetrical approach. Sequent calculus as a compiler intermediate language paul downen luke maurer zena m. The third sequent calculus we consider is the labelled sequent calculus llbii introduced in, a variation on the calculus l of ours whose differences we will explain later. A sequent calculus for integer arithmetic with counterexample generation philipp ru. The only axiom schema of sequent calculus is a a, where a is any logical formula. Proof search in the sequent calculus for firstorder logic.
There are two sorts of inference rules in sequent calculus. The first sequent calculi systems, lk and lj, were introduced in 19341935 by gerhard gentzen as a tool for studying natural deduction in firstorder logic in classical and intuitionistic versions, respectively. For the love of physics walter lewin may 16, 2011 duration. The second is a family of sequent calculi, which we call intuitionistic calculi, in which premises of the form with 6. Herbelin 224, 225 studies a modified sequent calculus ljt that limits the number of cutfree proofs so that the map to normal deductions becomes injective. A sequent calculus for integer arithmetic with counterexample. Therefore, this program limits the number of quantifier rules l\forall and r\exists for each path of the proof at most five. Sequent calculi for skeptical reasoning in predicate. Introduction in this work we propose an extension of the gentzen sequent calculus 3, that we call z sequent culculus, in order to obtain a proof theory of modalities. This is a tutorial introduction to sequent calculus, starting from a certain natural style of proving, and based on an example. We can also prove new theorems in predicate logic that we previously. There are at least two logical rules for every propositional connective and every quantifier.
In the sequent calculus, the name sequent is used for the construct, which can be regarded as a specific kind of judgment, characteristic to this deduction system. This chapter will jump directly into the two problems that the subject was invented to solve. Many courses in theoretical computer science suffer from. Smullyan, firstorder logic 1969, dover reprint and then observe that the sequent rules are the tableaux rules written upsidedown. Introduction in this work we propose an extension of the gentzen sequent calculus 3, that we call zsequent culculus, in. I left logical rules in sequent calculus correspond to elimination rules in natural deduction. We extend the notion of a sequent obtaining what we call a 2sequent. For the obtained calculus we prove a cut elimination theorem. We present this as a an exercise in constructing the abstract model \ sequent calculus. Similar derivations can be made for all of the qs equivalence relations, but now you are permitted to take a shortcut and introduce them all as sequent introductions. The advantage of a sequent calculus over a hilbertstyle axiomatized system is that it is amenable to automated theorem proving. Notes on sequent calculus with exercises randall holmes october 9, 2006 in this handout, we modify the propositional part of the calculus in the book to allow more than one formula on the right of the which we insist on putting between the premises and the conclusion.
This also happens for the contingency sequent calculus cc. Secondorder classical sequent calculus philip johnsonfreyd abstract we present a sequent calculus that allows to abstract over a type variable. This implies the need for sequent rules with countably many premises, and such rules are employed. Introduction sequent calculus was originally introduced by gentzen as a way to better understand the properties of natural deduction in particular the eliminability of cut. I the translation expands the deduction downwards to the root. A sequent calculus and a theorem prover for standard conditional logics 3 knowledge, this is the. Introduction to sequent calculus and abstract logic programming. Introduction skeptical consequence is a notion common to all forms of nonmonotonic reasoning. Of course, the proof search of firstorder logic is undecidable. Main differences and relations between sequent calculus and natural deduction.
After presenting the rules making up the system, we consider the structure of these rules from both a pragmatic and \aesthetic viewpoint. Epistemic logic, conditional logic, neighbourhood semantics, sequent calculus, decision procedure. What are the main differences between the sequent calculus and the natural deduction independently of if were working with classical, intuitionistic or another logic. Introduction to sequent calculus tudor jebelean risclinz johannes kepler university october 25, 2019 abstract this is a tutorial introduction to sequent calculus, starting from a certain natural style of proving, and based on an example. The propositional clausal sequent calculus consists of only three rule schemata. Do you know any good introductory resource on sequent. Modal logic frank pfenning lecture 8 february 9, 2010 1 introduction in this lecture we present the sequent calculus and its theory. I want to tell you about a neat system called the sequent calculus. In this view, a sequent calculus proof gives a recipe for the construction of a natural deduction proof. Sequent calculus properties of the translation direction of expansion i right logical rules in sequent calculus correpond to introduction rules in natural deduction. Ive tried to make these notes as self contained as possible and so all the information needed to read through them is either from an algebra or trig class or contained in other sections of the. A tutorial on computational classical logic and the sequent calculus.
Our goal is to obtain a decision procedure for the logics under. Proof search in the sequent calculus for firstorder logic with equality master thesis in computer science arno ehle mat. An introductory overview 1023 the truth values are written as t, b, n and f, taken from true only, both true and false, neither true nor false and false only respectively. From the subformula property to cutadmissibility in. A cutfreegentzenstylesequentcalculusfor the modal logics5. A sequent calculus for type theory 451 in this section we present a system for pro ofsearch that avoids all cuts, is complete and is sound provided that types are checked independently.
Hence, a clause set s is unsatisfiable if the sequent s. An introduction to proof theory in handbook of proof theory, edited by s. We also show how intercalation derivations lead to more compact proof terms, and how to extract proof terms from sequent calculus derivations. The wellknown multipleconclusion calculus for intuitionistic logic see 38 is the prototype example for an intuitionistic calculus. With such an algorithm the sequent calculus trainer can be improved. We present this as a an exercise in constructing the abstract model \sequent calculus. I read about the sequent calculus that it presents numerous analogies with natural deduction, without being limited to the intuitionistic case in proof and types by jy girard. Thus, backward proof search in lsbbi can be structured so that we. All of the same sequents and theorems from propositional logic are valid in predicate logic as well. Main differences and relations between sequent calculus and. Inference rules, like in natural deduction, directly model syntactical. We introduce classical sequent calculus, in a way that enables a very simple proof of completeness, with cut elimination as a corollary.
975 1379 1501 1398 399 82 1214 905 771 1323 350 522 192 117 1282 1302 661 1368 937 92 268 611 562 355 607 318 39 974 632 1424 1344